"... at the conclusion of the final set, they went home to Ark, leaving behind one of their dishes, a pair of pliers, a pair of shoes, a pick, and a hammer." --The Oregen Tale
Very sharp font and shiny well-curved borders. Looks like a solid pick indeed.
Also, new hypothesis -- Stanley found the Arkenpick and attuned to it without anybody (including him) knowing what just happened. He's used it ever since, and rocking out has been a power of the Pick, not the Hammer. (This doesn't make the Hammer's skillset completely sensible, but it helps.)