timh wrote:Not sure if anyone has mentioned this before, but suggestions can't make somebody do something that goes completely against what they want. So at some level, Stanley -did- consider appointing Parson as Chief Warlord again. The idea didn't strike him as absurd enough to break the suggestion.
No it wasn't, I just wanted to do that...
I don't think Maggie had that much to struggle with loyalty. Actually, her duty would compell her to convince her Lord make the decision that will serve him best. And as timh pointed out, a suggestion can't make him do things he wouldn't do anyway. Maybe all that kept him from appointing Parson was his "stubbornness out of principle", a.k.a. "what he thinks is leadership". Note that he actually looks happy after making the decision. And he did give her permission to give him the suggestion, so that works out for Maggie.
One thing: The lack of bonus will hurt Wanda's group in the battle. Against the archers and casters a attack bonus will be not good for much, but Jetstone has a small flying stack of nine unipegataurs and some orlies. If all arrows and air defences are shot used, they will send that stack, maxed out with knights and warlords (and some dittomancy), to mop up the rest. Then a direct CW bonus could be critical, because every croaked enemy is a reinforcement.
Oh, and a random speculation, that has mearly no foundation in anything in the comic: Could Ford have been the CW for the time of the attack? If the position of the CW can be assigned mutliple times during a day, it would make sense to appoint Ford and then re-assign as soon as he has fallen. He'll die anyway, but that way he can maximize the damage. At least that would explain why they waited to appoint a new CW in Wanda's group after the battle. If they had appointed before, Ford's group would have gotten at least the side-wide CW bonus. Maggie knew that he would fall anyway, so there would be another chance to make Parson CW.
I love uncroaked Dora. I love an anonymous friend even more.
Only one man has understood me, and even he has not!