Roszlishan wrote:moose o death wrote: i have no problem with speculation, i submit enough ideas other people do not like, but that speculation is counterproductive as it starts out with clearly impossible situations and builds from there. that would be like speculating barrack obama was the second gunmen in the JFK assasination. it's based on two things that could never plausibly be connected.
Exactly so!
I'm delighted that to see that someone else has a similar aesthetic dividing plausible and enjoyable speculation from wild and bizarre invention; thank you for laying it out clearly.
Roszlishan


OneHugeTuck wrote:Roszlishan wrote:moose o death wrote: i have no problem with speculation, i submit enough ideas other people do not like, but that speculation is counterproductive as it starts out with clearly impossible situations and builds from there. that would be like speculating barrack obama was the second gunmen in the JFK assasination. it's based on two things that could never plausibly be connected.
Exactly so!
I'm delighted that to see that someone else has a similar aesthetic dividing plausible and enjoyable speculation from wild and bizarre invention; thank you for laying it out clearly.
Roszlishan
Y'all missed my point. The point being, speculation is fun. It's fine if you think yours is better, but still, it's all speculation.
Erfworld is nothing but wild and bizarre invention. I like wild and bizarre invention. I guess you don't Ros. That's cool. To each our own.
Back to Moose's refute, we don't know for sure whether or not a (chief) warlord in any particular city has any say in production or not. Do we know where the Plaid clan comes from? Facial structures...possibly true, but speculation also.
I'm having fun. Hope you are too.
Dwagon_Cwoaker wrote:Irrelevant! eveyrone knows the comedian killed JFK.


Maybe not such a good plan.Lord Kasavin wrote:HailGreen28 wrote:Can't believe nobody's commented on the main plot point of the update. After taking Unaroyal, Ansom wants to launch an all-out decapitation strike at Jetstone's capital.
I'd like to know why. Ansoms loyalty isn't in question, and he undoubtedly know Jetsone's strengths and weaknesses better than anyone in Stanley's employ.
Because its a good plan? OK, they just steam rolled Unaroyal by taking using one single powerful force to engage multiple weaker forces one at a time, and in the process converted the defeated to decrypted enlaring the GK army. Ansom feels this strategy is unlikely to work twice as opposing armies will now concentrate on either a single point defense or massive counterstrikes. Which one is Jetstone likely to do? Go on offense, obviously. It's what they do. The "counter" for the all out allied strike is a quicker strike at an enemy's capital, hopefully while it has only a typical guard. Jetstone also appears to be one of the more powerful sides and one of the most ideologically driven to oppose Stanley. Plus, the fact that he used to be a Jetstone man means that nation looms large in Ansom's mind.
Highly doubtful that capturing a ruler turns all his units to your side.Gez wrote:HailGreen28 wrote:1. The Heir Issue: Jetstone has a new Chief Warlord. But does Slately have an heir? What if Ansom is that heir? Could Ansom literally take control of ALL Jetstone if he croaks Slately soon?
Croaking? Why not capturing? It would seem logical that heirloom and positions of command are lost when croaked, and not restored when uncroaked/decrypted. For a standard unit, that's not a problem since they have no title. But capture Slately and don't croak him, and you get control over all the Jetstone forces.
joosy wrote:Intriguing insight in the mind of a decrypted unit.. he needs rest but no 'food' apparently. And he is fanatically loyal to Wanda. So much so he is jealous of "Parson" (notice that Wanda calls him that.. everyone else calls him Lord Hamster.)

Step back and try not to screw up, until I have a better grasp on the situation.asparagus wrote:Okay everyone knows that Stanley is the manager from hell. What would you do if you suspected you yourself might be the manager from hell? How would you handle it?
Yosarian wrote:raphfrk wrote:Presumably, Ossomer has been promoted to Heir. Ideally, both Ossomer and Slateley need to be taken out on the same turn. Otherwise, Ossomer will become king as soon as Spacerock falls.
My hunch would be that with royals, there is a natural line of sucession; that is, if Stateley and Ossomer both were croaked at once, but Tramennis lived, that Tramennis would become King.
I suspect that the expensive (and rarely done) business of appointing a non-royal heir is only needed if you don't have a royal heir; if you have one, they're probably your heir automatically.
Yosarian wrote:Heh. I just had a scary idea.
I wonder if Wanda would be able to convince Ansom that it would be in Stanly's own good for him to be, well, "popped again", that is, killed and decrypted.
From the way we've learned about loyalty before, a warlord is capable of doing something that he thinks is in his warlords own good even if it's against his orders, right?
Which would end up with Wanda being the ultimate puppet master, in total control over the guy who is theoretically her overlord.
shneekeythelost wrote:Actually, neither of these are correct. Remember, Jillian was officially declared the Royal Heir. That means that if your hypothesis is correct, FAQ would not have fallen, and she would not have become a Barbarian, because they still had an heir.
If Jetstone falls, Ossomer and Tramennis become Barbarians, until they can retake something to rule.


Users browsing this forum: ftl and 3 guests