Strengths: Taming Dwagons, Heaving Lightning, Cracking Things
Weaknesses: Inconspicuousness, Clarity of Purpose, Personal Taste in Friends
Known properties include:
- Taming and control of dwagonsErf-b1-p031Erf-b1-p079
- Controlling lightningErf-b1-p113
- Turning roughly every fifth walnut cracked with it into a pigeonErf-b1-p004
- Turned the one bird croaked with it into a walnutErf-b1-p114
- Hitting a dwagon pacifies it, knocking it out for remainder of turnsummer-updates-007
It should be noted that some of the pigeons thus created turn back into walnuts after being croaked (or once cooked, or perhaps simply contain walnuts somewhere inside).Erf-b1-p037 The exact effects of this tool striking living things are mostly unknown. So far in the comic, one Orly has been struck with the Arkenhammer in combat; it turned into a walnut.Erf-b1-p114
The hammer likely opened up the ability to pop dwagons at Gobwin Knob.
Stanley, a Warlord who cannot cast spells, uses an electrical effect to take down a Chief Warlord (Caesar Borgata) and his entire stack, emerging entirely unscathed from the engagement. This effect appears to be powerful enough to compare to the associated Disciplines of the other two Arkentools. The question, then, is which Discipline does this effect belong to?
Since Thinkamancy and Croakamancy are Fate Axis Disciplines, some readers feel that all associated Disciplines should be Fate aligned. Fate magic being the determining factor in attunement reinforces this belief.
The case for Shockmancy
The first case for Shockmancy compares the electrical effect's resultsErf-b1-p113 to that of the known Shockmancy resultErf-b1-p126. The two results are similar, suggesting they come from the same Discipline.
The case against: Shockmancy is Erf-aligned, not Fate-aligned. Some readers feel that the visual, magic word, & thematic elements of the Scroll spell and the Van Der Graff hammer effect are different enough that they are different Disciplines. The other powers of the 'hammer would indicate the 'hammer is not exclusive to Shockmancy, even if it is dominated by it. (This would contrast with the seeming uniformity of the other tools' powers - unless the Arkendish covers Foolamancy.)
The case for Carnymancy
Carnymancy has not yet been defined, but is probably defined by either the term "Carny" or "Carnival".
The first case suggests that since electrical shows have been included in carnivals, an electrical effect is Carnymancy.
The second case looks at the Arkenhammer itself. The 'hammer has the appearance of a squeaky toy hammer, which can be a prize given by Carny's at a carnival. Hammers are also featured prominently in the form of the carnival game that tests one strength by striking a mallet to make a bell ring.
The 'flight' attributed to the hammer seems to be levitation - having only been used to raise straight up, both in actual use and in foolamancy cover - sideshow magicians would often create the illusion of levitation.
Changing pigeons to walnuts is reminiscent of making things appear, disappear, and trade places - classic small-scale magic. Pigeons were often used in such tricks, and walnuts are sometimes used in "shell games," another simple deception.
It is worth noting that Stanley, the hammer's attuned user, thinks of the hammer's abilites in terms of being 'tricks,' and asks Wanda if her Tool can also do tricks. If there is one Discipline that would cover tricks (other than Foolamancy), it's Carnymancy.
The case against: choosing a Discipline based on the appearance of the hammer itself is inconsistent with the association by effect of the 'pliers, though arguably the 'dish's form could be related to the communication aspects of Thinkamancy.
The case for Changemancy
Changemancy has not yet been defined, but is probably defined by an effect of changing one thing into another.
Since the Arkenhammer changes birds into walnuts and vice versa, it does have an effect that associates with Changemancy.
The flight affect of the 'hammer may be from a change of the Type of the wielder to Flying.
Real World References
It was pointed out that a company named Stanley manufactures hand tools.
Thor, the god of storms (could create thunder and lightning) from Norse mythology, owned a hammer named Mjolnir.